Vanity Of Vanities
“All is vanity.” So the Preacher tells us — and some three thousand years later, the question still remains undecided how we are to react to those words.
On a simple level, the past few centuries have established conclusively that all is vain in the etymological sense — all is void of greater meaning. And many pseudointellectuals prattle on proudly about this absence of meaning as a justification for hedonism and all other sorts of self-indulgence — and they take their “scientific” nihilism as a sign of profundity, having failed to realize that the scientific confirmation of the absence of purpose in the universe (or meaning, which is far less to ask for) is not the solution to the problem Ecclesiastes posed, but a deepening of it. Nihilism as a solution to our teleological questioning is like the application of leeches to cure infection: the wound is only deepened rather than healed.
The problem cannot be solved by proclaiming that “all is vanity” and leaving it at that because we are alive — and living is the perpetual evaluation of all around us. Unjust, self-centered and near-sighted as we may be, we must make judgments, we must find what is meaningful.
A good life involves the perpetual reconsideration of this problem — but problem not like a problem of mathematics that admits of a final solution, but as being a musician is a problem, a perpetual striving towards an unattainable goal that is approached ever closer — aproached as the limit of some infinite process.